| Platinum | Sugarmonkey Bar |
| Gold | Cuckoo For Cookies |
| Silver | Cindy's Carrot Cakes |
| Bronze | The Newfie Sugar Mama |
| Top Pick | Blissful Bites & Beyond |
| Top Pick | Cedars Bakery & Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Divine Cakes |
| Top Pick | Higher Ground Coffee House |
| Top Pick | Ymm Cookie House |