| Platinum | The Cheesecake Boutique |
| Gold | Ruth's Sweets and Treats |
| Silver | Cobs Bakery |
| Bronze | Sugarmonkey Bar |
| Top Pick | Cuckoo For Cookies |
| Top Pick | Cupcakes by K |
| Top Pick | Evermore Kookies |
| Top Pick | Kayla's Kitchen |
| Top Pick | The Newfie Sugar Mama |
| Top Pick | Ymm Cookie House |